Decide dismisses affirmative motion go well with towards UT Austin

A federal decide on Monday dismissed a lawsuit accusing the College of Texas at Austin of racial discrimination in admissions, bringing an finish to a long-running authorized battle that each presaged and was pre-empted by final 12 months’s Supreme Court docket determination banning affirmative motion.

The lawsuit, initially filed in 2019 by College students for Honest Admissions—the identical group that prevailed in comparable circumstances towards Harvard College and the College of North Carolina at Chapel Hill—had been dismissed as soon as earlier than, in 2021. However SFFA appealed the choice. Two years later, after the Supreme Court docket struck down affirmative motion final June and UT Austin modified its admissions coverage accordingly, SFFA motioned for the attraction to maneuver ahead regardless, arguing that the college’s new race-neutral insurance policies had been nonetheless in violation of the choice.

Critics of the attraction stated it was an try to develop the scope of the SFFA v. Harvard and UNC rulings past the textual content of the choices—an effort that conservatives have taken up over the previous 12 months to affect all the things from hiring practices to scholarship standards. David Hinojosa, director of the Academic Alternatives Mission on the Legal professionals’ Committee for Civil Rights Beneath Regulation and a member of UT Austin’s protection crew, lauded the dismissal as a rejection of that motion.

“Regardless of their efforts to increase the Supreme Court docket’s Harvard ruling and goal to additional diminish variety on campuses, their technique backfired,” he wrote in an announcement.

The go well with towards UT Austin was one in every of two filed by SFFA that remained unresolved even after the Supreme Court docket ruling towards Harvard and UNC. The opposite, towards Yale College, was settled out of court docket after each side agreed to a change in admissions insurance policies on the establishment. When Inside Larger Ed reached out to UT Austin for remark concerning this go well with final September, a spokesperson declined to touch upon the continued litigation, however specialists predicted that the college would resist settling and try to get the case thrown out totally.

UT Austin has been on the heart of the authorized challenges to race-conscious admissions because the early 2010s, when affirmative motion was upheld twice in favor of the college—as soon as by a circuit court docket and the Supreme Court docket in 2013, and once more by the Supreme Court docket in 2016—within the long-running Fisher v. College of Texas circumstances.