Fruit Grown within the Soil of Obedience
Eight-year-old Evelyn was arrested as a result of she needed to put on a cow hoodie at school.
Seven-year-old Malachi was arrested after a shoving match with one other little one who had teased him about one among his drawings.
The low-end estimate is that we arrest 130 kids between 5 and 9 yearly, though the quantity might be a lot greater. Black kids make up 43 % of these arrested although they solely comprise 15 % of children in that age vary. I haven’t got information on this, however I count on that autistic kids, or kids who’re in any other case neuro-atypical, are additionally over-represented in these arrests.
There may be by no means a motive to arrest a toddler. Ever. Even when they bring about a gun to highschool. Even when they make threats. The legal justice system will do nothing however hurt.
Kaia’s grandmother says that for the reason that arrest she has been watching her granddaughter die “little by little, day after day.” All of those kids have suffered from post-traumatic syndrome, been in remedy, and are petrified of each faculty and the police.
I do not blame the academics. I do not blame the cops. I blame all of us, you and me included.
We stay in a society that enshrines phrases like “freedom” and “liberty,” however our establishments, like faculties and the police, are centered, like lasers, on compliance, particularly in relation to kids, particularly in relation to Black kids. Particularly in relation to kids who understand the world in another way.
Who cares if a toddler wears sun shades or a cow hoodie? However in fact it wasn’t about these issues. It is about kids who stood their floor, who opted for freedom or liberty over obedience. In different phrases, they behaved as our myths about ourselves as a nation would have them behave. And for that, the adults of their lives felt they need to crush them.
And I blame myself. I do not work in these faculties. Certainly, I’ve spent greater than a decade right here as a critic. I am not a cop. I’ve by no means known as the cops, even once I arrived to search out transients sleeping inside the varsity or on the playground. Even when one among them threatened me with a stick studded with rusty nails. I did not name the cops as a result of I feared what they’d do within the identify of compliance. I’ve marched within the streets in opposition to the excesses of the police. But I nonetheless blame myself as a result of I stay in a society that explicitly values obedience over freedom.
We’re so sick with this that we arrest five-year-old as a result of they really feel extra comfy sporting sun shades indoors.
We’re so sick that Kaia’s instructor insists that she would by no means have a toddler arrested, but her personal pupil was arrested. We’re so sick that the officer who handcuffed Kaia objected that she was a “child,” but this child was arrested.
French thinker Voltaire as soon as mentioned, “Those that could make you imagine absurdities could make you commit atrocities.”
Arresting younger kids, handcuffing them, forcing them into squad vehicles, reserving them, taking mugshots — all of it — is an atrocity. And our tradition of obedience, of compliance in any respect prices, even when it is nearly sun shades, cow hoodies, or perhaps a shoving match, is the absurdity that we imagine.
I am sure that some folks studying right here have already manufactured, of their minds, a method to blame these kids or their dad and mom for the arrests. I am certain that some have thought, “perhaps they’d it coming” or that generally the one factor that works is the companion absurdity of “robust love.”
Most of us, I hope, are outraged by the thought of arresting “infants.” It is a straightforward, excessive factor over which to be outraged, however we ought to be equally outraged over kids being required to ask permission to make use of the bathroom or compelled to stroll in straight strains via the hallways or to sit down quietly of their seats whereas a instructor drones on about irrelevant issues. We ought to be equally outraged by the meeting line mechanisms by which we course of our kids, standardizing them via assessments and rating them by grades. We ought to be equally outraged by a tradition that cuts down all of the tall poppies, hammers down the nails that stick up, and values classroom administration over anything.
However how will we ever train the kids if they do not first study to obey? That’s the absurd query that results in atrocity. Arresting kids is the fruit that grows from the soil of obedience.
Freedom, liberty, autonomy: that’s what should come first. It should be the best worth if we’re to ever develop into self-governing folks. That is what historical past, science, and expertise have to show us. It’ll solely be after we, as a society, can study see kids as free folks that we are going to lastly perceive what it means to be free ourselves. Till then, I am afraid, we shall be doomed to commit atrocities within the identify of absurdities.
******
